| 1856-57 |
R. B. Smelling |
| 1857-60 |
Eli Stone (2 terms) |
| 1861-63 |
F. E. Ensign |
| 1864-65 |
A. P. VanDuzer |
| 1866-67 |
L. N. Kelchaw |
| 1868-71 |
Edward Shearer (2 terms) |
| 1872-75 |
T. A. Bantz (2 terms) |
| 1876-84 |
H. B. Gillis (4 terms) |
| 1885-86 |
William McCouaghy |
| 1887-90 |
J. S. Beard (2 terms) |
| 1891-94 |
James F. Lodge (2 terms) |
| 1895-98 |
Herbert R. Raynes |
| 1899-02 |
James F. Lodge |
| 1903-10 |
Charles J. Luttrell (2 terms) |
| 1911-14 |
Frank W. Hopper |
| 1915-18 |
W. J. Neilson |
| 1919-22 |
James M. Allen |
| 1923-34 |
Charles E. Johnson (3 terms) |
| 1935-38 |
James Davis |
| 1939-46 |
Charles E. Johnson (5 total terms) |
| 1947-50 |
Fred W. Burton, Jr. |
| 1951-58 |
Floyd Merrill (2 terms) |
| 1959-70 |
Albert H. Newton, Jr. (3 terms) |
| 1971-74 |
Jane Skanderup |
| 1975-78 |
Charles E. Hurley |
| 1979-82 |
Steven B. Plumer |
| 1983-90 |
Charles Slote (2 terms) |
| 1991-2004 |
Peter F. Knoll (4 terms*) |
| 2005-present |
J. Kirk Andrus (appointed 4/11/05, elected 6/30/06) |
| |
* Mr. Knoll resigned before completing his 4th term. Mr. Andrus was appointed to fulfill the term. |